How To Make A Diminished Value Car Insurance Claim: Get What Your Car Really Owes You

Even after a flawless repair, your car might not be worth what it was before the accident. This loss in value is called diminished value, and you might be eligible to recoup those lost bucks through a diminished value claim. This guide will equip you with the knowledge to navigate the process of filing a diminished value claim and get the compensation you deserve.

Understanding Diminished Value

Diminished value boils down to the decrease in market value of your car after an accident, even if it’s been meticulously repaired. This depreciation happens because potential buyers are wary of vehicles with a history of accidents, regardless of the repairs. There are two main types of diminished value:

  • Inherent Diminished Value: This is the most common type and reflects the market’s perception of a car that’s been in an accident.
  • Repair-Related Diminished Value: This results from poor repair quality or the use of aftermarket parts, reducing the car’s value below what it would be with proper repairs using OEM parts.

Is Diminished Value Covered by Insurance?

Not all insurance policies cover diminished value claims. It depends on your state’s regulations and the specific terms of your policy. Here’s a breakdown:

  • Your Insurance Company: Some states allow you to file a diminished value claim with your own insurance company, especially if you have uninsured motorist coverage and the at-fault driver has no insurance.
  • At-Fault Driver’s Insurance: This is generally the more preferred route. You’d file a claim with the insurance company of the driver responsible for the accident.

Tip: Review your insurance policy documents to see if diminished value claims are covered.

Steps to Take for a Diminished Value Claim

Filing a diminished value claim involves gathering documentation, proving the value loss, and negotiating with the insurance company. Here’s a step-by-step guide:

  1. Confirm Eligibility: Check your state’s laws and your insurance policy to ensure diminished value claims are allowed.

  2. Gather Documentation: The more evidence you have, the stronger your case. Here’s what you’ll need:

    • Accident report
    • Police report (if applicable)
    • Repair estimates and invoices
    • Pre-accident car value appraisals (ideally from Kelley Blue Book (KBB) or NADA)
    • Photos of the damage before, during, and after repairs

  3. Get Diminished Value Appraisals: These appraisals determine the exact amount of value your car has lost due to the accident. You can use:

    • Online calculators: KBB and NADA offer free valuation tools.
    • Professional appraisers: An independent appraisal strengthens your claim but comes at a cost.

  4. File Your Claim: Contact the relevant insurance company and initiate the diminished value claim process. Be prepared to provide all the documentation you’ve gathered.

  5. Negotiate the Settlement: Insurance companies might offer a lower amount than your appraisal suggests. Be prepared to negotiate based on your evidence.

Here are some additional tips to strengthen your claim:

  • Act Quickly: The sooner you file your claim, the easier it is to gather accurate information.
  • Maintain Detailed Records: Keep copies of all paperwork related to the accident and repairs.
  • Be Persistent: Don’t get discouraged if the initial offer isn’t ideal. Negotiate and present your case effectively.

FAQ

Q: How much can I expect to recover in a diminished value claim?

A: The recovery amount varies depending on the severity of the accident, the car’s pre-accident value, and the quality of repairs. It can range from a few hundred dollars to thousands.

Q: What if the insurance company denies my claim?

A: If your claim is denied, you can try to negotiate with an adjuster or request a supervisor review. If that fails, you might need to consider legal representation.

Q: Can I file a diminished value claim if I was at fault for the accident?

A: It’s less likely. Diminished value claims are typically pursued against the at-fault driver’s insurance company.

Q: What are some reasons an insurance company might deny a diminished value claim?

A: Common reasons include:

  • The damage was minor and shouldn’t affect the car’s value.
  • You lack sufficient evidence to prove diminished value.
  • Diminished value claims aren’t covered under your policy or state law.

The Importance of Documentation in Diminished Value Claims

Having a strong case hinges on meticulous documentation. Here’s a breakdown of key documents and why they matter:

  • Accident Report: This official record details the accident scene, parties involved, and preliminary damage assessment. It serves as a foundational piece of evidence.

  • Police Report (if applicable): A police report, if filed, can provide a more detailed account of the accident, including witness statements and officer observations. This strengthens your claim, especially in cases with disputed fault.

  • Repair Estimates and Invoices: These documents detail the repairs performed, parts used, and associated costs. Ensure they come from reputable repair shops and clearly outline the repairs done to address the accident damage.

  • Pre-Accident Car Value Appraisals: Obtaining appraisals from Kelley Blue Book (KBB) or NADA before the accident establishes your car’s market value at its pre-damaged state. This creates a benchmark to compare against the diminished value after the repairs.

  • Photos of the Damage: High-quality photos capture the extent of the damage before, during, and after repairs. This visual documentation aids the appraiser in assessing the severity of the accident and the repairs undertaken.

Going the Extra Mile with Documentation:

  • Maintenance Records: A well-maintained car with a documented service history can counter the diminished value to some extent. It demonstrates that the car was in good condition before the accident.

  • Comparable Sales Evidence: Find listings of similar cars (year, make, model, mileage) that haven’t been in accidents. This helps establish the market value a non-damaged car would hold. You can find such listings online or through dealerships.

Remember: The more comprehensive your documentation, the stronger your case. It demonstrates the severity of the accident, the repairs performed, and the impact on your car’s value.

Finding the Right Diminished Value Appraiser

Diminished value appraisals are crucial for determining the exact amount your car’s worth has declined. Here’s how to find the right appraiser:

  • Qualifications: Look for appraisers certified by professional organizations like the National Association of Certified Automobile Valuators (NACAV) or the American Society of Appraisers (ASA). These certifications ensure the appraiser has the expertise and experience to accurately assess diminished value.

  • Experience: An appraiser with experience in handling diminished value claims specifically for your car’s make and model is ideal. They’ll be familiar with common repair scenarios and their impact on value.

  • Reputation: Research online reviews and ask for recommendations from body shops or mechanic shops you trust. A good reputation indicates the appraiser delivers reliable and defensible valuations.

  • Cost: Diminished value appraisals typically range from a few hundred to several hundred dollars. Get quotes from multiple appraisers before making a decision.

What to Expect During the Appraisal:

  • The appraiser will inspect your car, examining the damage and the repairs performed.
  • They’ll review your documentation, including accident reports, repair invoices, and pre-accident appraisals.
  • They’ll research comparable car sales data to determine the market value difference.
  • Finally, they’ll provide a detailed report outlining their findings and the diminished value estimate.

The Benefits of a Professional Appraisal:

While online calculators offer a starting point, a professional appraisal carries more weight with insurance companies. Here’s why:

  • Detailed Analysis: A professional appraiser considers various factors impacting diminished value, like repair quality, frame damage, and the car’s history.

  • Credibility: A certified appraiser’s report holds more credibility with insurance adjusters compared to online valuations.

  • Stronger Negotiation Power: A professional appraisal strengthens your position when negotiating a settlement with the insurance company.

Negotiating Your Diminished Value Claim Settlement

Once you have all your documentation and appraisal in order, it’s time to negotiate the settlement with the insurance company. Here are some key strategies:

  • Know Your Value: Be familiar with the diminished value appraisal and understand how it was calculated.

  • Start High: Don’t be afraid to negotiate from a higher starting point to leave room for compromise.

  • Present Your Case Clearly: Explain the accident, the repairs performed, and the impact on your car’s value using clear and concise language.

  • Highlight Documentation: Use your documentation to substantiate your claims. Point out the accident report, repair invoices, pre-accident appraisals, and the professional appraisal.

  • Be Patient and Persistent: Negotiation might take time. Be patient, persistent, and professional in your communication with the adjuster.

Please fill the required fields*